Aarhus Convention under threat
Protections for people and community groups who try to bring legal cases against developers or councils on environmental grounds could be much harder in the future if the Government has its way.
The UK has been signed up to the Aarhus Convention since 2005. Under the treaty, when an individual brings an environmental legal claim, they are usually protected by a cost cap that means they pay only £5,000 of the other side’s costs if they lose. For organisations, the cost cap protection is usually £10,000.
The purpose of this is to ensure legal challenges about the environment are not prohibitively expensive for individuals and public interest groups. Without it, many cases would be impossible.
The Guardian has recently reported that the Government has been in ‘private meetings’ about removing cost cap protections under Aarhus convention. Read the article here.
In 2023, a group of NGOs - the RSPB, Friends of the Earth and the Environmental Law Foundation, issued a worrying report that Judicial Reviews brought on environmental grounds were already in decline and should this decision be made by Labour, it could result in a further, drastic reduction.
So are these cases a waste of time? Well no, around 35% of environmental Judicial Review applications are granted permission to proceed to a full hearing and that 10% were ultimately successful (compared to just 3% of all Judicial Reviews). Of course, many will be settled without ever getting to court.
Please write to your MP about how important the Aarhus protection is - the easiest way is to use Write to Them.
It would be deeply shocking for a Labour government, with its historic commitment to fairness and social justice, to remove the Aarhus protections that enable ordinary people and community groups to challenge potentially unlawful decisions affecting the environment. Individuals and organisations take on considerable personal and financial burdens to uphold environmental law on behalf of us all, and when they succeed, it is the public and the environment that benefit.
Wanna read an article by those who don't like Judicial Reviews? You can do so here.